Documentation for Benjamin L. Vining - Esther Kellyhouse


Census Data

  1890 1900 1910 1920 1930 1940
Benjamin L. Vining ? 34 46 56 68 dead
Esther (Kellyhouse) Vining ? 29 39 48 56 dead
    child Vining ? dead
[see note below]
    child Vining ? dead
[see note below]
    child Vining ? dead
[see note below]
    Mabel Vining ? 13 [married? and] living in separate household
    Edward L. Vining ? 11 married and living in separate household
    Frank W. Vining 7 19 living in separate household
    Benjamin L. Vining Jr. 5 16 married and living in separate household
    Hazel May Vining 1 13 married and living in separate household
    child Vining dead
[see note below]
    child Vining dead
[see note below]
    Albert J. Vining 10 19 married and living in separate household
    Steven Vining 7 16 married and living in separate household


1900 Taylor, Cortland County, New York - dwelling 134, family 139. According to the 1900 census, Esther had given birth to 8 children, 3 of whom were dead as of that census date.



1910 Cincinnatus, Cortland County, New York - dwelling 237, family 253. According to the 1910 census, Esther had given birth to 12 children, 5 of whom were dead as of that census date.



1920 Cincinnatus, Cortland County, New York - dwelling 137, family 147:



1930 Cincinnatus, Cortland County, New York - dwelling [unnumbered], family 71. Also living in this household in 1930 was Mad[e]line E. Parker (12 y., b. New York, likely a granddaughter of Benjamin L. and Esther even though the census reported that she was their "daughter").





Death Data

Gravestones for Benjamin L. Vining and Esther (Kellyhouse) Vining, in Cincinnatus Cemetery, Cincinnatus, Cortland County, New York (from Find A Grave):
   


Gravestone for Frank W. Vining, son of Benjamin L. Vining and Esther (Kellyhouse) Vining, in Cortland Rural Cemetery, Cortland, Cortland County, New York (from Find A Grave):