Census Data
1840 | 1850 | 1860 | 1870 | 1880 | 1890 | |
Cornelius W. Vining | ? | 33 | ? | 53 [see note below] | 62 | dead |
Zipporah (Clarke) Vining | ? | 32 | ? | 52 [see note below] | 61 | ? |
Daniel Devere Vining | ? | 10 | ? | dead | ||
Thaddeus Subsequie Vining | 8 | ? | 29, married [see note below] | ? | ? | |
Robert Emmett Vining | 6 | ? | married and living in separate household | |||
Frank Clarke Vining | 4 | ? | 23 | ? | ? | |
Charles Fournier Vining | 6 months | ? | 21 | married and living in separate household | ||
Alice Cecelia Vining | ? | 18 | married and living in separate household | |||
Thomas Paine Vining | ? | 13 | 22, married and living in this household | ? | ||
Joseph Eason Vining | ? | 11 | 20 | ? |
Death Data
Gravestones for Cornelius W. Vining and Zipporah (Clarke) Vining, in East Liberty Cemetery, Liberty, Jackson County, Michigan (from Find A Grave):