| | 1820 | 1830 | 1840 | 1850 | 1860 | 1870 | 1880 | 1890 | 1900 |
| Ammi Vining | M 16–25 | ? | ? | dead
(lost at sea) | | | | | |
| Betsey (Strout) Vining | F 16–25 | ? | ? | ? | 62 | 71 | ? | ? | dead |
| Harriet S. Vining | | ? | ? | married [and living in separate household?] | | | | | |
| Harrison S. Vining | | ? | ? | married [and living in separate household?] | | | | | |
| Sarah S. Vining | | ? | ? | married [and living in separate household?] | | | | | |
| Betsey S. Vining | | ? | ? | ? | 38
[see note below] | | | | |
| Mary Angelia Vining | | | ? | ? | 28
[see note below] | 37
[see note below] | | | |
1820 Lisbon, Lincoln County, Maine [Lisbon is now in Androscoggin County.] The age of each member of this family in 1820 matches the expected age category in the 1820 census report.:
1860 Portland (Ward 3), Cumberland County, Maine - dwelling 1008, family 1483. By 1860, Mary Angelia Vining was married, to Joseph C. Witham, and she and her husband were living in the household of her mother. By 1860, Betsey S. Vining was married, to Harrison G. Soule, and she (but not her husband) was living in the household of her mother.:
1870 Brooklyn (Ward 10), Kings County, New York - dwelling 465, family 688. In 1870, Betsey (Strout) Vining was living in the household of daughter Mary Angelia (Vining) Witham and son-in-law Joseph C. Witham.:
