Documentation - Benjamin L. Vining

Census Data

	1890	1900	1910	1920	1930	1940
Benjamin L. Vining	?	34	46	56	68	dead
Esther (Kellyhouse) Vining	?	29	39	48	56	dead
child Vining	?	dead [see note below]
child Vining	?	dead [see note below]
child Vining	?	dead [see note below]
Mabel Vining	?	13	[married? and] living in separate household
Edward L. Vining	?	11	married and living in separate household
Frank W. Vining		7	19	living in separate household
Benjamin L. Vining Jr.		5	16	married and living in separate household
Hazel May Vining		1	13	married and living in separate household
child Vining			dead [see note below]
child Vining			dead [see note below]
Albert J. Vining			10	19	married and living in separate household
Steven Vining			7	16	married and living in separate household

1900 Taylor, Cortland County, New York - dwelling 134, family 139. According to the 1900 census, Esther had given birth to 8 children, 3 of whom were dead as of that census date.:

1910 Cincinnatus, Cortland County, New York - dwelling 237, family 253. According to the 1910 census, Esther had given birth to 12 children, 5 of whom were dead as of that census date.:

1920 Cincinnatus, Cortland County, New York - dwelling 137, family 147:

1930 Cincinnatus, Cortland County, New York - dwelling [unnumbered], family 71. Also living in this household in 1930 was Mad[e]line E. Parker (12 y., b. New York, likely a granddaughter of Benjamin L. and Esther even though the census reported that she was their "daughter").:

Death Data

Gravestones for Benjamin L. Vining and Esther (Kellyhouse) Vining, in Cincinnatus Cemetery, Cincinnatus, Cortland County, New York (from Find A Grave):

Gravestone for Frank W. Vining, son of Benjamin L. Vining and Esther (Kellyhouse) Vining, in Cortland Rural Cemetery, Cortland, Cortland County, New York (from Find A Grave):