Documentation - Cornelius W. Vining

Census Data

	1840	1850	1860	1870	1880	1890
Cornelius W. Vining	?	33	?	53 [see note below]	62	dead
Zipporah (Clarke) Vining	?	32	?	52 [see note below]	61	?
Daniel Devere Vining	?	10	?	dead
Thaddeus Subsequie Vining		8	?	29, married [see note below]	?	?
Robert Emmett Vining		6	?	married and living in separate household
Frank Clarke Vining		4	?	23	?	?
Charles Fournier Vining		6 months	?	21	married and living in separate household
Alice Cecelia Vining			?	18	married and living in separate household
Thomas Paine Vining			?	13	22, married and living in this household	?
Joseph Eason Vining			?	11	20	?

1850 Springfield, LaGrange County, Indiana - dwelling 873, family 877:

1870 Columbia, Jackson County, Michigan - dwelling 69, family 71. Listed at the beginning of this household were Thaddeus Subsequie Vining, his wife (Hattie Lewis, 23, b. NH), and their son (Clarence, 5 m., b. Michigan).:

1880 Columbia, Jackson County, Michigan - dwelling 85, family 88. By 1880, Thomas Paine Vining was married, and he and his wife (Viola) and daughter (Nina) were living in the household of his parents. Also living in this household in 1880 was Charles Grace (24, b. Michigan, servant).:

Death Data

Gravestones for Cornelius W. Vining and Zipporah (Clarke) Vining, in East Liberty Cemetery, Liberty, Jackson County, Michigan (from Find A Grave):