| | 1870 | 1880 | 1890 | 1900 | 1910 | 1920 |
| David B. Vining | 28 | 40 | ? | 60 | ? | dead |
| Lucy (Gordon) Vining | 24 | 41 | ? | 61 | ? | dead |
| Elnora Vining | 6 | [living? in separate household] | | | | |
1870 Cain, Greene County, New York - dwelling 376, family 435. Also living in this household in 1870 was Stephen Vining (24 y., b. New York), a younger brother of David B. Vining.:
1880 Windham, Greene County, New York - dwelling 131, family 134:
1900 Windham, Greene County, New York - dwelling 210, family 235:
