| | 1850 | 1860 | 1870 | 1880 | 1890 | 1900 |
| David Vining Jr. | 26 | [36 or 38?] | 45 | 56 | ? | ? |
| Cynthia A. (Cobb) Vining | 20 | [dead?] | | | | |
| Howard C. Vining | 8 m. | 10 | living in separate household | married [and living in separate household?] | | |
1850 Middleborough, Plymouth County, Massachusetts - dwelling 515, family 610:
1860 Middleborough, Plymouth County, Massachusetts - dwelling 326, family 410:
1870 Middleborough, Plymouth County, Massachusetts - dwelling 423, family 490. In 1870, David Vining Jr. was living in the household of a John C. Perkins.:
1880 Hanover, Plymouth County, Massachusetts - dwelling 400, family 428. In 1880, David Vining Jr. was living in the household of sister Mary S. (Vining) Thomas.:
