1850 Simsbury, Hartford County, Connecticut - dwelling 240, family 249. Also living in this household in 1850 was Allen Eno (59 y., b. Connecticut).:

1860 Southwick, Hampden County, Massachusetts - dwelling 128, family 129. Also living in this household in 1860 was John Vining (age 39 y., b. Connecticut).:

1870 Southwick, Hampden County, Massachusetts - dwelling 57, family 59:

1880 Southwick, Hampden County, Massachusetts - dwelling 5, family 5. Research is needed to determine if the Edwin A. Vining of 1880 is the same person as Edward C. Vining of 1860 and 1870. The age, birthplace, and wife's name are the same.: