Thank you to Vivi Wagner for her contributions to this page.
Census Data
| | 1880 | 1890 | 1900 | 1910 | 1920 | 1930 | 1940 |
| Edward Payson Vining | 33 | ? | 53 | 63 | [72?] | dead | |
| Annabel (Bodwell) Vining | 33 | ? | | | | | |
| Agnes E. (Brooks) Vining | | ? | 48 | 58 | 67 | ? | ? |
| Annabelle Vining | [living? in separate household] | | | | | | |
| Edward Vining | [living? in separate household] | | | | | | |
| Annabel Bodwell Vining | 3 | ? | living in separate household | | | | |
| Ellen Pauline Vining | 3 | ? | 23 | [living? in separate household] | | | |
1880 Omaha, Douglas County, Nebraska - dwelling 261, family 268:
1900 San Francisco (Assembly District 41), San Francisco County, California - dwelling 206, family 221:
1910 Brookline, Norfolk County, Massachusetts - dwelling 114, family 152:
1920 Brookline, Norfolk County, Massachusetts - dwelling 31, family 89:
Family Data
Photographs of Edward Payson Vining, author of An Inglorious Columbus (book cover shown below with an autograph from one of the copies):
Photograph of twins Ellen Pauline Vining (left) and Annabel Bodwell Vining (right):
Photograph of Annabel Bodwell (Vining) Otis and her signature:
Death Data
Gravestone for Annabel (Vining) Otis, daughter of Edward Payson Vining and Annabel (Bodwell) Vining, in Woodlawn Cemetery, Bronx, Bronx County, New York:
