| | 1870 | 1880 | 1890 | 1900 | 1910 |
| Elijah F[elden?]. Vining | 28 | 35 | ? | dead | |
| Avaline V. (Bailey) Vining | 27 | 39 | ? | 59 | ? |
| Devalston Vining | 1 | [dead?] | | | |
| Mary Vining | 1 m. | [dead?] | | | |
| Day Vining | | | ? | [living? in separate household] | |
1870 Salisbury Township, Meigs County, Ohio. Also living in this household in 1870 were William Bail[3]y (63 y., b. Virginia, farmer) and Phebe Bail[e]y (65 y., b. Virginia, keeping house), likely the parents of Avaline V. (Bailey) Vining, whose occupation was listed as "helps mother".:
1880 Rutland, Meigs County, Ohio. Also living in this household in 1880 were Phebe Bailey (75 y., b. Ohio), the parents of Avaline V. (Bailey) Vining, and Cornelia Roush (5 y., b. Ohio).:
1900 Scipio Township, Meigs County, Ohio - dwelling 217, family 218:
