| | 1820 | 1830 | 1840 | 1850 | 1860 | 1870 | 1880 |
| George Vining Jr. | M 26–45 | M 40–50 | M 50–60 | 60 | 70 | 80 | dead |
| Susan (Woods) Vining | F 16–26 | F 30–40 | F 40–50 | 52 | 62 | dead | |
| Alden Barr Vining | M under 10 | M 10–15 | M 20–30 | living in separate household | | | |
| Calcina Catharine Vining | F under 10 | F 10–15 | F 20–30 | living in separate household | | | |
| George Whitfield Vining | | [see note below] | M 20–30 [see note below] | living in separate household | | | |
| Jonathan Edwards Vining | | [see note below] | M 15–20 | [living? in separate household] | | | |
1820 Plainfield, Hampshire County, Massachusetts:
1830 Plainfield, Hampshire County, Massachusetts - Only 1 male 5–10 was reported for 1830.:
1840 Plainfield, Hampshire County, Massachusetts - It appears that George Whitfield Vining (b. 1822) was reported to be 20–30 rather than 15–20. Alternatively, the male 20–30 could have been a hired hand, George Whitfield could have been the male 15–20, and Jonathan Edwards could have been dead or living in another household.:
1850 Plainfield, Hampshire County, Massachusetts - dwelling 12, family 14. Also living in this household in 1850 was John Downing (laborer, 55 y., b. St. Domingo).:
1860 Plainfield, Hampshire County, Massachusetts - dwelling 1930, family 1953:
1870 Waterford Township, Camden County, New Jersey - dwelling 403, family 388. In 1870, George Vining Jr. was a boarder in the household of son-in-law William Robinson.:
