| | 1840 | 1850 | 1860 | 1870 | 1880 | 1890 |
| Israel Vining | M 30–40 | 42 | 52 | dead | | |
| Rebecca (Norton) Vining | | | | | | |
| Joan[n?] (Bigelow) (Haws) Vining | [F 30–40?] | 41 | 51 | 62
[see note below] | ? | ? |
| Nathaniel Haws Vining | M under 5 | 9 | 20 | married and living in separate household | | |
| James Seldon Vining | | dead | | | | |
| Henry Clay Vining | | 4 | 14 | 24
[see note below] | ? | ? |
| George Washington Vining | | 2 | 12 | 22
[see note below] | married and living in separate household | |
| Josiah Bigelow Vining | | dead? | | | | |
| Joshua Cushman Vining | | | 8 | 19
[see note below] | married and living in separate household | |
1840 St. Albans, Somerset County, Maine - Also living in this household in 1840 were a male 15–20 and a female 5–10.:
1850 St. Albans, Somerset County, Maine - dwelling 422, family 453. Also living in this household in 1850 were [...]tta Hawes (age 15 y., b. Maine) and David [...] Stewart (age 27 y., b. Maine). Were these possibly the male and female in question in the 1840 census (see above)?:
1860 St. Albans, Somerset County, Maine - dwelling 1, family 1:
1870 St. Albans, Somerset County, Maine - dwelling 210, family 213. In 1870, Joan[n] (Bigelow) (Haws) Vining was living in the St. Albans, Somerset County, Maine, household (dwelling 210, family 213) of son Nathaniel Haws Vining. Also living with this household in 1870 were Nathaniel Haws Vining's brothers Joshua Cushman Vining and George Washington Vining. Henry Clay Vining was a clerk living in the Union Township, Floyd County, Iowa household of a William Moore family.:
