Documentation - Israel Royal Vining - (1) [Mary or Mercy?] Tirrell; (2) Persis Harris

Census Data

	1840	1850	1860	1870	1880	1890
Israel Royal Vining	?	49	56	[dead?]
[Mary or Mercy?] (Tirrell) Vining	?
Persis (Harris) Vining	?	48	56	65	dead
[Caliste?] Vining	?	17	[living? in separate household]
Edward Vining	?	20	[living? in separate household]
Israel C. Vining	?	13	[living? in separate household]
Jane C. Vining	?	living in separate household	22	[living? in separate household]
Mary E. Vining		9	16	27	?	?
Augusta Vining		dead

1850 Hatfield, Hampshire County, Hempshire County, Massachusetts - dwelling 48, family 57:

1860 Hatfield, Hampshire County, Massachusetts - dwelling 242, family 245:

1870 Hatfield (Chesterfield post office), Hampshire County, Massachusetts - dwelling 257, family 302: