Documentation - James C. Vining - Abigail Willoughby

Census Data

	1840	1850	1860	1870	1875	1880
James C. Vining	20–30 [see note below]	38	?	54	dead
Abigail (Willoughby) Vining	?	28	?	50	54	59 [see note below]
Martha Vining	?	11	?	[living? in separate household]
Abigail Vining		9	?	[living? in separate household]
Robert H. Vining		2	?	[living? in separate household]
Richard Vining			?	18	18 [sic]	[living? in separate household]
Emma Vining			?	10	15	[living? in separate household]
George G. Vining				7	12	17
Laura E. Vining				2	7	12

1840 Covington, Tioga County, Pennsylvania. Only James was reported to be living in this household, but the "total" reported on the following page was 3.:

1850 [no town name given], Henry County, Illinois - dwelling 55, family 55:

1870 Cambridge, Henry County, Illinois - dwelling 233, family 239:

1875 [illegible town name], Republic County, Kansas - dwelling 83, family 84:

1880 Solomon Township, Norton County, Kansas - dwelling 2, family 2. By 1880, Abigail had married Silas Zenus Waters.:

Military Data

Military record of Robert H. Vining, son of James C. Vining and Abigail Willoughby:

Personal Data

Newpaper notice to creditors (from Tioga Eagle (Wellsboro, Pennsylvania), Wednesday, 26 October 1842, page 3, column 4):