1860 New Castle, New Castle County, Delaware - dwelling 446, family 436. Also living in this household in 1860 were Rebecca Vining (65 y., b. Delaware), Ellen Vining (16 y., b. Delaware), and Amanda Vining (16 y., b. Pennsylvania).:

1870 New Castle (S. D. No. 6), New Castle County, Delaware - dwelling 195, family 199: