| | 1900 | 1910 | 1915 | 1920 | 1925 | 1930 |
| David Frayer | | 34 (head) | 38 (head) | dead | | |
| Orpha M. Vining | 20 (servant) | 30 (wife) | 35 (wife) | 39 (mother, widowed) | 45 (servant) | 50 (servant) |
| Russell Dale Vining | 3 (nephew) | 13 (nephew) | | 23 (head) | | |
| Cora Frayer | | ? | 10 (daughter) | | | |
| Charles Vining | | father-in-law | 70 (father-in-law) | | | |
1900 Orpha as servant with son Russell (the head's nephew) in an unidentified Vining household.:
1910 Frayer household, with Russell labeled "nephew" of David and recorded under the surname Frayer.:
1915 Meredith, NY. Charles Vining (Orpha's father) was living with the family.:
1920 Orpha widowed and using her maiden name Vining, living with adult son Russell as head of household.:
1925 Orpha working as servant in the Oscar Fuller household.:
1930 Orpha as servant in the Mary L. Forsyth household, Albany Avenue. Marital status recorded as "single" (conflicting with the 1920 census's "widowed").:
