1930 1940 Scott Osborn Vining 28 38 Lillian (Eggers) Vining 28 38 Scott Ernest Vining 2 y., [6?] m. 12 Robert William Vining 1 y., [?] m. 11 Ruth Vining 9 Betty Vining living in separate household 1930 Esopus Township, Ulster County, New York - dwelling 83, family [129?]:

1940 Esopus, Ulster County, New York: