| | 1860 | 1870 | 1880 | 1890 | 1900 | 1910 |
| William Vining | 28 | 38 | 48 | ? | ? | dead |
| Celestia M. (Horr) Vining | 27 | 37 | 47 | ? | ? | ? |
| William F. Vining | | 4 | 14 | ? | dead | |
| Joseph Horr Vining | | | 6 | ? | ? | dead |
1860 Bennington Township, Morrow County, Ohio - dwelling 196, family 195. Also living in this household in 1860 was Andrew Horr (23 y., b. Ohio).:
1870 Ross Township, Vermilion County, Ohio - dwelling 46, family 46. Also living in this household in 1870 was Edwin Vining (20 y., b. Ohio), a farm laborer.:
1880 Ross Township, Vermilion County, Ohio - dwelling 311, family 326. Also living in this household in 1880 were farm laborers John Keller (22 y., b. Pennsylvania) and John Lambert (30 y., b. Pennsylvania), and domestic servant Emma [Salmons?] (23 y., b. Illinoia).: