Documentation - William H. H. Vining

Research opportunity

According to the 1900 census, Mary Elizabeth (Beal) Vining, had given birth to two children, both of whom were living as of the 1900 census. However, this is not consistent with the report of the 1880 census. Did Mary Elizabeth (Beal) Vining have more children, or was William H. H. Vining married more than once?

Census Data

	1870	1880	1890	1900	1910	1920
William H. H. Vining	30	40	?	dead
Mary Elizabeth (Beal) Vining	34	37 [sic]	?	64	?	?
Grace A. Vining	living in separate household	living in separate household	?	26	?	?
Mary L. Vining	?	10	?	[living? in separate household]
William Vining		[5 or 6?]	?	[living? in separate household]
Herbert Vining		3	?	[living? in separate household]
Charles Henry Vining			?	15	?	?

1870 Abington, Plymouth County, Massachusetts - dwelling 855, family 1064:

1880 Hingham, Plymouth County, Massachusetts - dwelling 248, family 297:

1900 Rockland, Plymouth County, Massachusetts - dwelling 5, family 5:

Death Data

Monument side for William H. H. Vining and Mary Elizabeth (Beal) Vining, in Maplewood Cemetery, Rockland, Plymouth County, Massachusetts (from Find A Grave):