| | 1850 | 1860 | 1870 | 1880 | 1890 | 1900 | 1910 |
| William Reed Vining | ? | 34 | ? | 54 | ? | dead | |
| Susan A. H. (Whitman) Vining | ? | 34 | ? | 54 | ? | 74 | 84 |
| Sarah Porter Vining | | 7 | ? | 26, married and living in this household
[see note below] | ? | living in separate household | |
| William Whitman Vining | | 5 | ? | married and living in separate household | | | |
| Jared Augustus Vining | | 3 | ? | 23 | ? | living in separate household | |
1860 Abington, Plymouth County, Massachusetts - dwelling 536, family 667. Also living in this household in 1860 was Cath[arine?] O. Brier (18 y., b. Ireland).:
1880 South Abington, Plymouth County, Massachusetts - dwelling 303, family 392. Also living in this household in 1880 were Frank N. Smith (28 y., b. Massachusetts, husband of Sarah Porter Vining) and Frank W. Smith (9 m., b. Massachusetts, son of Frank N. Smith and Sarah Porter Vining).:
1900 Whitman Township, Plymouth County, Massachusetts - dwelling 285, family 319. Also living in this household in 1860 was Susie MacPharlin [sic] (servant, 26 y., b. Massachusetts).:
1910 Whitman, Plymouth County, Massachusetts - dwelling [illegible], family 237. Also living in this household in 1910 were Susan W. Smith (granddaughter, 27 y., b. Massachusetts) and Susan McPharlin [sic] (servant, 26 y., b. Massachusetts).:
