| | 1860 | 1870 | 1880 | 1890 | 1900 | 1910 |
| William Reynolds Vining | 31 | 41 | 51 | ? | dead | |
| Martha G. (May) Vining | 34 | 42 | 53 | ? | 74
[see note below] | ? |
| Elnora F. Vining | 8 | 18 | ? | ? | 48 | ? |
| Charles Oliver Vining | 6 | 15 | married and living in separate household | | | |
| Lillian Martha Vining | 3 | 12 | ? | ? | [living? in separate household] | ? |
| Orilla Vining | | 8 | 19 | ? | [living? in separate household] | |
1860 Nodaway Township, Holt County, Missouri - dwelling 158, family 158:
1870 Nodaway Township, Holt County, Missouri - dwelling 26, family 26:
1880 Lewis, Holt County, Missouri - dwelling 61, family 64:
1900 Clay Township, Holt County, Missouri - dwelling 268, family 270. In 1900 Martha G. (May) Vining was living in the household of her daughter, Elnora T. (Vining) Keeble, and son-in-law. Also living in Elnora's household were two orphaned daughters (Carolyn Daisy "Carrie" and Julia) of her brother Charles Oliver Vining.:
